Saturday, February 16, 2008

Bud Lewis: Demolish Mill No. 5

Demolish Mill No. 5

Tuesday, January 29, 2008

Lewiston is currently considering the future of Bates Mill No.5. I must express my assessment of this building.

I am a registered professional engineer, and was chief engineer for Bates from 1954 to 1985, and an engineering consultant to Bates until 2000. This structure, erected in 1912, was an early example of reinforced concrete sawtooth roof construction, designed and built to then current standards and methods, which today are woefully inadequate.

Too many years of exposure to high humidity required for weaving, severe vibration from looms, and extreme temperature differentials, indoors to outdoors, have resulted in widespread cracks in the concrete roof, leakage, and subsequent reinforcing bar corrosion. Concrete from the roof has fallen on the weave room floor. Rusted reinforcing bars are visable throughout the area. Snow load capacity is now less than designed, which is less than today's building code requirements.

The building was erected on filled land next to the canal system, and suffers from settling foundations. This has resulted in the severe cracking of concrete at floor beam to column joints in one area. Extensive floor settlement has occurred in several areas.

An old Lewiston main sewer, bypassed in the 1970s, runs underneath the main canal and the middle of No. 5 Mill. Serious cave-ins have occurred in like environments at Bates Manufacturing's former Androscoggin, Bates, Hill and Edwards mills.

In my opinion, despite understandable sentimental feelings, this building should be demolished to make way for new construction meeting today's building codes and tomorrow's needs.

William B. Lewis, Auburn

Peter Steele: How to Attract Private Investment?

Peter Steele opined in the Jan 24th edition of the Twin City Times. Click on the image to link to the article.
Mike Carey
Lewiston

TCT Covers Jan 5th Public Meeting

Click on the image for the link to the entire article.

Mike Carey
Lewiston

Sun-Journal Article about Public Meeting

The Sun-Journal covered the public meeting. Click on the picture or title to read the full article and the comments.

Mulling over future of mill No. 5 Scores take up the challenge to create a new life for city's slumbering giant

,
Sunday, January 6, 2008

LEWISTON - More than 100 people bobbed their heads in unison on a tour of Bates Mill No. 5 Saturday, the warm-up to a brain-storming session on the future of the nearly century-old mill.

"You can see where the cotton dust is still hanging," said tour director and urban planner Steve Myers, as dozens of people craned their heads upward to look at the coated steel beams, remnants of the mill's heyday as the weave shed for Bates Manufacturing.

"Now watch your step," he added, as the the crowd obediently dropped its collective gaze to the uneven wood floors and continued on.

The tour through the 365,000-square-foot building - bigger than the Auburn Mall - was intended to give the crowd a sense of the historic structure before the Bates Mill No. 5 Task Force tapped them for ideas on what to do with it. But for some, it was already familiar terrain.

"Both my parents worked here," said Vic Gagnon, as he surveyed the old loom space. "This is L-A. This is what we're all about."... Finish Reading

Mike Carey
Lewiston

Jan 5th Public Meeting

The City Council mandate included the following: "The Task Force shall conduct at least one public hearing prior to issuance of the final report".
Most of the 15 citizen members of the Task Force had no little or no professional experience with the structural, financial and functional topics inherent in the re-use of a building or site on the scale of Mill #5. After considering and debating possible uses, we commissioned a series of professional studies to guide our deliberations.
We decided to have two public meetings, one before we received professional reports, and the second after.
The first meeting, on January 5th, had three elements:
  • A tour of the facility lead by Steve Myers of Platz Associates. Much of the information from the tour is available in a fact sheet.
  • Public Meeting participants received a handout about the building that included some information abstructural facts and information about historical operating losses.
  • A presentation by co-chairs Mike Carey and Jonathan Labonte. The size of that presentation prevents it from being posted online, but it is available by emailing batesmill5@gmail.com
  • Small group conversations about possible uses for the building and land. Notes from those conversations can be found at: notes.
The Sun-Journal published a story the next day.
Architect Gabrielle Russell sent the Task Force a letter after the meeting with a forceful argument for the building's preservation. She included a document detailing the costs and financial benefits of Green Building.

Mike Carey
Lewiston

Mill #5 Structural Fact Sheet

Allan Turgeon, Property Manager for the Bates Mill Complex, has prepared a fact sheet for Bates Mill #5. Some of the topics addressed include:
  • Structural Condition
  • Environmental Condition
  • Hydroelectric Substation owned by FPL Energy
We welcome you to read the fact sheet.

Mike Carey
Lewiston

Western Gateway District

The Task Force recognizes that the Mill #5 block is also a gateway—perhaps The Gateway—to the City of Lewiston and that it was necessary to consider its future use through that prism.
The City of Lewiston's Western Gateway includes the land between the river and two canals in addition to the Bates Mill complex. Click on the picture for a larger plan:

The Lewiston City Council approved the creation of a Western Gateway Development District at the October 16th, 2007 City Council Meeting.

Mike Carey
Lewiston

2001 ERA Conference and Meeting Facility Analysis

Economics Research Associates (ERA) completed a Conference and Meeting Facility Analysis in February, 2001 for LA Excels. The study was to "evaluate the development potentials of the project."
ERA found the following competitive attributes, the positive:
  • Central location within Maine
  • Excellent regional road access
  • Availability of local demand generators
and the negative:
  • Residual "mill town" image
  • Small concentration of state/federal employees
  • Size and quality of hotel/motel inventory
  • Lack of direct air access
  • Availability of visitor amenities and services
  • Proxmity to Augusta and Portland.
Based on their analysis, ERA felt that L-A could capture a greater share of the state and regional meetings market and could accommodate state/regional conventions, trade and consumer shows and local non-meeting events.
ERA suggested the following building program:
  • Total building: 35,000-40,000 SF
  • Exhibit/Ballroom: 12,000-20,000 SF
  • Meeting Rooms: 15 high-quality rooms, 10,000 SF
  • Need minimum 2.4 acres
  • Provision for parking 525 cars
The study can be found here. There are three appendices: Appendix A, Appendix B, and Appendix C.

This study was updated in 2003 and 2007 using the same methodology.


At the same time they did a Regional Center for the Arts Analysis. In that study, they found demand for (among other things):
  • Two new performance spaces, one 200-400 seat space designed for theatrical performances and one 300-500 seat acoustical space designed for orchestral and choral performances.
Mike Carey
Lewiston

2001 Statewide Meeting and Convention Facilities Feasibility and Siting Study

Conventions Sports & Leisure (CSL) completed a study in March, 2001 for the Maine Meetings and Conventions Committee. The study looks at Lewiston-Auburn as one of six regions statewide (Portland, Augusta, Bangor, Aroostook, and Coastal/Mountain were the others), and is focused on the compatibility of all sites.

Portland and Bangor were identified as the markets for large convention facilities (70,000 SF and 30,000 SF of sellable space respectively). Lewiston-Auburn was slated for a small center to attract smaller conference and other events tied to area colleges and other local events (+/-15,000 – 20,000 SF sellable space).

Lewiston-Auburn market strengths were access to Portland, growth of downtowns and surrounding areas, and the existence of a college and cultural focus. Weaknesses were a lack of a local major airport, size of the corporate base, and the a significant convention quality hotel base.

The executive summary is posted online. To receive the full report email ljeffers@ci.lewiston.me.us.

Mike Carey
Lewiston

2000 Protze Concrete Report

Herman Protze, an international expert on concrete, investigated the concrete in Mill #5 on April, 2000. The purpose was “to assess to condition of structural reinforced concrete beams and to evaluate the feasibility of repairing deteriorated concrete.” Click on image for report.
He found that “the deteriorated concrete is amendable to repair and mitigation… A rough estimate of the cost of repairing and mitigating the exterior of the mill building is approximately $330,000… The repair and coated concrete will provide an additional life value of the structure of over an additional 50 years.”

Please read the report’s entire executive summary.

Mike Carey
Lewiston